How can a song you’ve heard a hundred times suddenly move you to tears?
Rob Jacobs was lying on a couch at Johns Hopkins with eyeshades on and headphones over his ears. He had volunteered for a study exploring psilocybin and spiritual practice. As Henryk Górecki’s Symphony No. 3 played, he heard something in the music that he could still describe a decade later. It seemed to hold the beauty and sadness of being alive at the same time. “It literally moved me to tears,” he recalled. www.hopkinsmedicine.org
Perhaps you know which song could do that to you. Maybe it’s the one your dad always turned up in the truck, or the track you and a friend stayed up playing long after everyone else had gone to bed. Then again, you might put on that very song during an emotional moment and find yourself wishing for quiet.
Both reactions turn up in research on music and psilocybin, the psychedelic compound in magic mushrooms. People have described music bringing a memory vividly to mind, helping them stay with a difficult feeling, or becoming so irritating that they wanted it to stop. What makes those accounts interesting is how much depends on the particular listener, song and moment. pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov
Why can a familiar song feel brand new?
Think of a song you know well enough to tap the drum fill on your steering wheel. You know exactly when the singer comes back in. Then one day you catch a second voice singing underneath the chorus. It’s been there for years. For the next three plays, it’s the only part you want to hear.
That ordinary experience offers one way to understand what listeners describe on mushrooms. A recording gives you several things to follow at once. If your attention settles on the bass player, you might discover that the saddest verse in your favourite song has a surprisingly playful rhythm underneath it. The notes are familiar. What catches your ear, and what it means to you, can change.
Researchers have a clearer picture of the emotional experience than of why any particular instrument suddenly stands out. In interviews after psilocybin therapy, people described music evoking personal memories and giving shape to feelings they had struggled to express. One listener on a mushroom forum offered a wonderfully specific example. Pink Floyd’s Remember a Day brought back the sense of innocence and wonder they associated with childhood. Another person could hear the same recording and remember an entirely different afternoon. pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov
Why can the same song comfort one person and overwhelm another?
Imagine hearing the opening bars of a song your dad played every Sunday morning. One day, you can almost see him making coffee. Another day, what strikes you first is how long it’s been since you heard his voice. Even a song you love can meet you differently each time.
In a study led by Mendel Kaelen, researchers interviewed 19 people who had received psilocybin therapy for treatment-resistant depression. They paid attention to what they called resonance. Did the music fit what the listener was feeling as it played? Participants recalled moments when a piece helped them approach something painful. They also described discomfort when a selection seemed to push them toward an emotion that felt wrong at the time. pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov
That gives “calming music” a more personal meaning. A steady kick drum gives one listener a dependable beat to come back to. To somebody craving stillness, the same kick can sound like a knock at the door every second. And sometimes a song barely registers at all. Bill Richards, the psychologist who developed the Johns Hopkins playlist, described music as something participants could draw on when they wanted structure, even after stretches when they hardly noticed it. www.hopkinsmedicine.org
How do researchers choose music for psychedelic therapy?
Listen to Samuel Barber’s Adagio for Strings and notice how long the musicians make you wait. The strings climb. Just when the phrase seems to have reached its highest point, it climbs again. Richards chose it for the approach to the peak of a psilocybin session because that musical rise and release echoed what participants might be feeling. www.hopkinsmedicine.org
The Johns Hopkins research playlist ran seven hours and forty minutes, with extra music to accommodate sessions of different lengths. Richards selected pieces for arrival, the onset of effects, the ascent, the peak and the gradual return. Participants listened through headphones while the two guides usually heard the selections through speakers. Even during long periods of silence, everyone in the room knew what had just come through those headphones. www.hopkinsmedicine.org
There’s a listening experiment you can try sober. Play Adagio for Strings once while you’re going about your day. Another time, sit down and follow the strings all the way to the silence after the climax. See which moment you remember the next morning.
Where does sound therapy fit in?
A sound bath asks something different of your ears. Picture a practitioner striking a singing bowl. First you hear the tap. Then a bright, wavering tone hangs above a lower hum. Eventually the sound grows so faint that you become aware of the room around you again. There’s no chorus to anticipate. Listening for the moment the note disappears can hold your attention all by itself.
Singing bowls have been studied for relaxation, anxiety and mood. Some studies report short-term benefits, although the research varies in quality. Several paired bowls with practices such as yoga or meditation, which makes the contribution of the sound itself difficult to isolate. Whether bowls offer a particular benefit during a psilocybin session remains an open question. pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov
Do you want a voice to follow or room for your own thoughts?
Think of a lyric you always sing a little louder than the rest. Maybe you remember who first played it for you. Maybe you’ve finally reached the age the songwriter was when they wrote it, and a line you’ve sung a thousand times suddenly makes sense.
An instrumental gives you a different kind of listening pleasure. Hear the way Eddie Hazel bends a note in Funkadelic’s Maggot Brain. You might hear grief at the beginning of the phrase and defiance by the end. The friend beside you might hear tenderness in precisely the same place. If you ever want to get past asking someone whether they liked a song, try asking which moment they’d rewind. www.reddit.com
What music do people recommend for a psychedelic experience?
One listener in a mushroom forum asked for something calming they could play from beginning to end. Someone promptly recommended King Gizzard & the Lizard Wizard’s Nonagon Infinity and cheerfully acknowledged how energetic it was. That exchange captures the fun of asking strangers for music. Sometimes the recommendation tells you as much about the person offering it as it does about the record. www.reddit.com
Ambient, lo-fi, psybass and psychedelic rock
The rock, ambient and melodic electronic selections below came from mushroom discussions. The lo-fi and psybass entries are Mystic Fungi listening picks for readers who enjoy mellow beats or deeper bass.
| If you like… | Song, album or playlist | What to listen for |
|---|---|---|
| Ambient music and nature sounds | Jon Hopkins — Music for Psychedelic Therapy | Let the quiet textures come into focus. This is an album by musician Jon Hopkins. The similarly named Johns Hopkins research playlist is a separate collection. www.reddit.com |
| Lo-fi and mellow beats | Nujabes — Modal Soul, or a Lofi Girl playlist | Follow a short melodic phrase as it repeats. Once you know it by heart, little shifts in the drums become easier to hear. |
| Psybass and psychedelic downtempo | Kalya Scintilla, Desert Dwellers or Quanta | Follow the low bass pulse for a few bars, then listen higher up for the small percussion sounds moving around it. A track can feel slow underneath and busy on top. |
| Melodic electronic mixes | Lane 8 — Seasonal Mixtapes | Listen for the handoff between tracks. Sometimes the mood has already changed before you realise a new song has begun. www.reddit.com |
| Spacious psychedelic rock | Pink Floyd — Echoes | Remember the opening ping. By the time the band finds its way out of the strange middle passage, the return of a familiar groove can feel like an event. www.reddit.com |
| Progressive rock and storytelling | King Crimson — The Court of the Crimson King | One listener described feeling as though they were visiting the court in the song. Hear how the relatively intimate verses open into that enormous chorus. www.reddit.com |
| Fast, tightly wound guitar music | King Gizzard & the Lizard Wizard — Nonagon Infinity | Each track tips into the next. Part of the fun is trying to catch the exact moment the band has carried you into a different song. www.reddit.com |
| A whole-album classic | Pink Floyd — The Dark Side of the Moon | Stay with it through a track change. Voices, sound effects and instruments carry ideas across boundaries you miss when you only hear the singles. www.reddit.com |
Psychedelic funk, electric jazz, dub and heavier listening
Some of these suggestions came from people discussing psychedelic experiences directly. Others came from music fans with a more specific question, like what to play after Maggot Brain, or where to find a reggae interpretation of the Grateful Dead.
| If you like… | Song or album | What to listen for |
|---|---|---|
| Psychedelic funk and soul | Funkadelic — Maggot Brain | Eddie Hazel gives individual notes room to bend, hang and fade. If Górecki made you curious about how much feeling a symphony can carry, hear what one guitarist does with that same space. www.reddit.com |
| Electric jazz | Miles Davis — In a Silent Way | Notice how much happens in the gaps between trumpet phrases. A listener recommended this record in a discussion about long psychedelic instrumentals. www.reddit.com |
| Glitch and experimental bass | Tipper — Vection | Little electronic sounds appear and vanish around a low groove. A Tipper fan named it as a favourite after discovering his music during a psychedelic experience. www.reddit.com |
| Progressive metal | Tool — Lateralus | Tap along and see where the accents catch you by surprise. One listener in a mushroom discussion singled out the title track as a moment they anticipated while playing the album. www.reddit.com |
| Dub reggae | Roots of Creation — Grateful Dub | Pay attention to what happens after a drum hit. The echo trails away while the bass keeps the song moving. Grateful Dead fans recommended the collection to someone looking for Jamaican-style dub interpretations. www.reddit.com |
| Jazz fusion | Mahavishnu Orchestra — You Know, You Know | A repeating guitar figure gives you something to hold onto while the drums change the feel underneath it. Try it alongside the Miles Davis pick and see which drummer catches your ear first. www.reddit.com |
More picks for fans of soulful bass music
In an electronic-music discussion, a fan asked what to play if they already loved GRiZ’s Chasing the Golden Hour and Daily Bread’s Cloud Conductor. The replies pointed toward Pretty Lights, Gramatik and Vincent Antone. If a warm sample and a good bass line are what make you turn the volume up, this is the corner of the collection to explore. www.reddit.com
| If you like… | Artist or mix | What to listen for |
|---|---|---|
| Laid-back funk and soul | GRiZ — Chasing the Golden Hour series | The bass has bounce, and the melodies have room to breathe. Start here if you want a sunny, unhurried groove. |
| Hip-hop beats and heavier bass | Daily Bread — Cloud Conductor series | Catch a soulful sample before the drums come in. Listen to how the same phrase takes on a different swing once the beat arrives. |
| Soulful electronic music | Pretty Lights | Pick out a short vocal sample and follow it. As the chords and beat shift, the same few words can land differently. |
| Instrumental hip-hop and funk | Gramatik | Listen for the small guitar or keyboard accents between drum hits. Those offbeat details give your shoulders something to move to. |
| Electro-soul and funky bass | Vincent Antone | Follow the exchange between a bright melodic phrase and the heavier bass that answers it. A pick for the listener who’s already out of their chair. |
Which song would you hear again for the first time?
You can skip a track halfway through. You can choose quiet. In a supported session, a simple “Could we turn this down?” tells the person beside you what you need. The listeners researchers interviewed found different things comforting, and a piece that felt right at one point could feel intrusive at another. pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov
A decade after his session, Rob Jacobs still remembered Górecki. There’s probably a piece of music you remember with that kind of precision, too. Maybe you’ve forgotten the year, but you know who had the aux cord. You know the words somebody got wrong. And if the first few seconds came through a speaker right now, you’d turn to them before either of you said a word. www.hopkinsmedicine.org
If you could hear one song again for the very first time, which one would you choose?
Sources, Further Reading & Music Recommendations
Research on Psilocybin, Music and Sound Therapy
- Johns Hopkins Medicine — Playlist for a Psychedelic Journey
- The Hidden Therapist — How Participants Experienced Music During Psilocybin Therapy
- Changes in Music-Evoked Emotion After Psilocybin Therapy for Depression
- Tibetan Singing Bowls and Adult Health — A Systematic Review
- Therapeutic Effects of Singing Bowls — A Review of Clinical Studies
Listener Stories and Music Recommendations
- Favourite Artists and the Childhood Memories Behind Pink Floyd’s “Remember a Day”
- Jon Hopkins, Lane 8 and King Crimson — Album and Mixtape Recommendations
- Immersive Albums, From Jon Hopkins to Pink Floyd
- Song Suggestions, Including Pink Floyd’s “Echoes”
- A Request for Calming Music That Turned Up King Gizzard & the Lizard Wizard
- Listeners’ Favourite Music, Including Tool’s “Lateralus”
- Funkadelic’s “Maggot Brain” and Other Guitar Instrumentals
- Long Psychedelic Instrumentals, From Miles Davis to Mahavishnu Orchestra
- Discovering Tipper — “Vection” and Other Listener Picks
- Dub Reggae Interpretations of Grateful Dead Songs
- Soulful Bass Picks for Fans of GRiZ and Daily Bread
The lo-fi and psybass selections in the article are Mystic Fungi editorial picks.
